Weekly Column: Common Sense

***Common Sense***

This last week in Springfield has me thinking about common sense more and more. Democrats on the Judiciary Committee have run roughshod over what I believe are common sense solutions. It certainly seems that common sense isn’t so common, and I began to wonder how the term originated.

Common sense made its first appearance in the book De Anima (Of the Soul), written by famed Greek philosopher Aristotle in 350 B.C. He described common sense more as a sense of common things and also as the place where our consciousness comes from because, “it makes us aware of having sensations at all.”

Centuries later, the Romans shaded Aristotle’s idea of common sense in three ways. First, the Roman, “sensus communis,” represented widely accepted ideas that originate from our souls. Second, it referred to mankind’s natural intellectual capacity. Lastly, it was used to describe the public attitude or spirit.

Common sense continued to evolve over the centuries. It developed the definition it has today through the contribution of Thomas Reid. Reid was the founder of the “Scottish School of Common Sense”. Reid wrote, “If there are certain principles, as I think there are, which the constitution of our nature leads us to believe, and which we are under a necessity to take for granted in the common concerns of life, without being able to give a reason for them – these are what we call the principles of common sense; and what is manifestly contrary to them, is what we call absurd.”
Reid’s philosophy was a strong influence on many of our own Founding Fathers, including Thomas Jefferson and John Adams. It also had a significant impact on the father of modern capitalism, Adam Smith.

I agree with W. Somerset Maugham who wrote, “With a little common sense, a little patience, and a little sense of humour you can live well on this planet.” I was disappointed to witness how much common sense was lacking in votes taken by the House Judiciary Subcommittees and the Judiciary Criminal Committee last week.

The Sex Offenses and Sex Offender Registration Subcommittee voted down House Bill 4318. After a rapist gets out of prison they can move right next door to their victim. You read that correctly. There are no living restrictions for a convicted rapist when it comes to their victim. HB4318 established a 1 mile radius living restriction between a rapist and the victim.

A registered sex offender cannot live within 500 feet of a school. Surely it is reasonable to protect rape victims from living next door to their rapist. The Subcommittee Democrats argued that rapists do not need any additional restrictions after being released from prison.

The Judiciary Criminal Committee voted down House Bill 4586. As I have written before, HB4586 extended the same protections to Illinois DCFS employees that DHS workers, corrections officers, police officers, fire fighters, and other first responders have under current law. We filed this bill in response to the horrific and brutal attack on DCFS investigator Pamela Knight in September of last year.

Pamela Knight’s family issued a statement in response to the vote. Her daughter, Jennifer Hollenback wrote, “Speaking for myself as a lifelong democrat, I understand that enhancing criminal penalties doesn’t always deter crime. I don’t believe that philosophy applies to this bill. We are not talking about mandatory minimums. We are talking about legislation that protects social workers working in some capacity for the state of Illinois… I am devastated by the vote cast by the democrats, in the Judicial Criminal Committee. We are supposed to be advocates for social issues. We are supposed to be a party for the people. How can we ask child welfare workers to keep children safe, if we can’t keep our child welfare workers safe?”

To Jennifer, her family, and to DCFS workers across the state of Illinois, I say, I will not give up the fight. We cannot let this injustice happen to other families.

Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick said, “We have drained common sense out of our politics. The more we focus on tactics and games, the more good people check out and give up.” I agree. We need common sense. We need to put partisanship aside and get things done for Illinois. My sincere hope is that my colleagues across the aisle start by reconsidering their votes on HB4318 and HB4586.


If you have any additional thoughts or ideas, you can reach me or Sally at 815-232-0774, or visit my website at www.repbrianstewart.com and use the form to send me an e-mail.

No comments :